Massachusetts Democrats Propose Gag Rule on Pro-Life Pregnancy Centers

As Texas continues to take greater steps forward in protecting preborn children and building a truly Pro-Life state, sadly other states are moving backwards.

In Massachusetts, House Bill 377 (HB 377) by Representative Tram T. Nguyen, is a controversial piece of legislation that has recently raised significant concerns over its potential to restrict the free speech rights of pregnancy resource centers (PRCs). This bill, also known as the Pregnancy Resource Center Gag Rule, is another example of the disturbing efforts of pro-abortion Democratic Party to hinder Pro-Lifers from offering Life-affirming support and services to women.

Tragically, HB 377 threatens to impose vague and undefined restrictions and fines on the speech of PRCs in Massachusetts, effectively silencing their Pro-Life views. This bill aims to restrict the freedom of speech of PRCs by claiming the centers may not use “deceptive advertising”, while not providing a definition for “deceptive advertising”. This lack of clarity opens the door to subjective interpretation and has the potential to allow discriminatory and unwarranted penalties for PRCs. 

By doing so, the bill threatens to suppress the expression of Pro-Life views, undermining our fundamental First Amendment rights. This restriction not only violates the principles of free expression but raises questions about the true motives behind the legislation.

Furthermore, the bill unfairly singles out PRCs, while offering preferential treatment to abortion clinics by imposing no such restriction on these groups. This disparity further undermines the principles of fairness and equal opportunity, impeding women’s right to access crucial support and information during a critical time.

If passed, this legislation would limit the comprehensive information available to women facing unexpected pregnancies, hindering their access to vital community resources they need in order to have support in choosing Life. Thankfully, Massachusetts Citizens for Life has been leading a bold effort to oppose this legislation and hopefully prevent it from passing into law.

HB 377 was considered in public committee on July 24, where not a single individual supporting the proposed anti-Life measure testified. Instead, 23 individuals, including a member of Texas Right to Life’s Legislative Team, testified both in-person and virtually against the bill. These voices emphasized the importance of PRCs having free speech and the need for women to have access to choices and resources offered though these centers.

PRCs play a pivotal role in providing emotional support, education, and resources to women facing unplanned pregnancies. These centers are often vital community resources that offer assistance beyond pregnancy-related matters, including parenting support, adoption services, and material aid for mothers and babies in need, such as diapers, wipes, cribs, maternity and baby clothes, and more.

HB 377 threatens to hinder PRCs’ charitable work by impeding their ability to communicate openly with those seeking help. This in turn may jeopardize the well-being of pregnant women and their babies, potentially leaving them without the comprehensive support they need to make informed decisions.

As Myrna Maloney Flynn, President of Massachusetts Citizens for Life, stated in her testimony opposing HB 377, “[HB 377] would be unconstitutional for the state to practice this clear form of censorship. Like each of you, Massachusetts Citizens for Life believes our women deserve the best possible care. But this bill is not the way to provide it.”

HB 377 is yet another example of the Left’s discriminatory tactics against PRCs and highlights that the only “choice” they see as acceptable to offer women is that of abortion. As the legislative process continues, it remains critical for lawmakers to carefully consider the implications of this bill and for citizens to diligently oppose these sort of anti-Life efforts. Such efforts will not stop at one bad bill from Massachusetts.